Welcome to the www.therapiesguide Shop

Therapies for Gout Relief and Prevention
Complementary Therapies that can help anyone Stop Smoking
Complementary Therapies for achieving Weight Loss
Depression Relief and Prevention using Alternative Therapies
Allergy Relief and Prevention using Natural and Alternative Therapies
Therapies suitable for Sleep Disorders
Therapies Suitable During Pregnancy and Childbirth
Therapies suitable for Children or Babies
Alternative and Complementary Therapies available for animals
Therapy Breathing Exercises
Food Based Therapies
Herbal-Therapy The Guide to Herbalism, Herbal Medicines
Guide to Complementary Therapies and Alternative Medicine
Therapy Related Articles & Notes
Books on Complementary and Alternative Therapies
Therapy E-Books Guide
Therapy Related DVDs

Information about Acupressure
Information about Acupuncture and Acupuncturists
Information about Alexander Technique and Practitioners
Information about Angel Therapy and Angel Therapists
Information about Aromatherapy and Aromatherapists
Information about Bach Flower and Bach Flower Therapists
Information about Balneotherapy and Balneotherapy Practitioners
Information about Bio-Energy and Bio-Energy Practitioners
nformation about Biofeedback and Biofeedback Practitioners
Information about Body Talk and Body Talk Practitioners
Information about Bowen Therapy and Bowen Therapists
Information about Chelation and Chelation Practitioners
Information about Cognitive Therapy and Cognitive Therapy Practitioners
Information about Craniosacral Therapy and Craniosacral Therapy Practitioners
Information about the Feldenkrais Method and Feldenkrais Practitioners
Information about Homeopathy and Homeopaths
Information about Hopi Ear Candles and Hopi Ear Candling
Information about Hydrotherapy and Hydrotherapy Practitioners
Information about Hypnotherapy and Hypnotherapists
Information about Indian Head Massage and therapists
Information about Iridology and Iridology Practitioners
Information about Kinesiology and Kinesiology practitioners
Information about Light Therapy and Light Therapy Practitioners
Information about Light Therapy and Light Therapy Practitioners
Information about Massage Therapies used in Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
Information about Naturopathy and Naturopaths
Information about Osteopathy and Osteopaths
Information about Psychotherapy and Psychotherapists
Information about Qigong and Qigong Practitioners
Information about Raindrop Therapy and Raindrop Therapy Practitioners
Information about Reflexology and Reflexologists
Information about Reiki and Reiki Practitioners
Information about Relaxation Therapy and Relaxation Therapy Practitioners
Information and guide to Shamanism
Information about SHEN Therapy and SHEN Therapists
Information about Shiatsu and Shiatsu Practitioners
Information about Somatic Therapy and Somatic Therapy Practitioners
Information about Trager Therapy and Trager Practitioners
Information about Trigger Point Therapy and Trigger Point Practitioners
Information about Yoga and Yoga Teachers
Information about Zero Balancing and Zero Balancing Practitioners
 


 


Relax while you work
Massage London
Offers onsite massage / corporate massage in London


On-Line Shop for Therapy Themed Products And Gifts
On-Line Shop for Therapy Themed Products And Gifts



On-Line Shop for Therapy Themed Products And Gifts
On-Line Shop for Therapy Themed Products And Gifts


 

 

 

 

 

 




 

Home Page
Find an Alternative Therapist in your Area
Guide to Alternative, Complementary & Holistic Therapies
Submit a New Therapist Listing entry
Amend an existing Therapist Listing entry
Alternative & Complementary Therapies Courses, Training & Workshops
Therapists & Therapy Providers for Animals
On-Line Shop for Therapy Themed Products & Gifts

Therapy Related Articles & Notes

 A SCIENTIFIC ASSESSMENT OF NLP
Author: Dylan Morgan
 

I am sure that we have all read and learned something about the theory and techniques of Neurolinguistic Programming (NLP). But it is possible that some of us have not had the opportunity to study it in enough detail to determine the validity of the ideas which are involved in it.

A few years ago Dr. Heap, Principal Clinical Psychologist for Sheffield Health Authority and lecturer at Sheffield University, did a very careful and thorough study of all the research that has been done into certain claims of NLP, citing 70 papers in all.

Specifically he was looking into the idea of the Primary Representational System (PRS), which is supposed by NLP to be a very important concept. It is claimed that people tend to think in a specific mode: visual, auditory, kinaesthetic, olfactory or gustatory, of which the first three are the most common. NLP claims that it is possible to determine the PRS of a person by noticing certain words that she or he uses which will reveal the mode. It is also claimed that the direction of eye movement is an indicator of the PRS.

The reason why it is said to be important for the therapist to determine the PRS of a client is that it is supposed greatly to enhance rapport if one then matches the clients PRS.

These three assertions are capable of being put to controlled tests to determine how far they are true. Dr. Heap, who is also Secretary of the British Society of Experimental and Clinical Hypnosis, ploughed through the literature to summarise the results of many workers and found the following.

Although the results have been mixed, the hypothesis that a person has a PRS which is observed in the choice of words has been found not to hold by the great majority of researchers. The hypothesis that a person has a PRS which can be determined by the direction of eye movements found even less support.

The third hypothesis which was looked at is the practical one of whether or not we can improve our relationship with a client by matching the presumed PRS. Again the answer is a resounding NO. There is no evidence that focusing on the presumed modality adds anything to the widely recognised finding that matching general characteristics of verbal and nonverbal communication may facilitate rapport. It is interesting that one researcher, Cody, found that therapists matching their clients' language were rated as less trustworthy and less effective!

Dr. Heap comes to the following conclusion:

'The present author is satisfied that the assertions of NLP writers concerning the representational systems have been objectively and fairly investigated and found to be lacking. These assertions are stated in unequivocal terms by the originators of NLP and it is clear from their writings that phenomena such as representational systems, predicate preferences and eye-movement patterns are claimed to be potent psychological processes, easily and convincingly demonstrable on training courses by tutors and trainees following simple instructions, and, indeed, in interactions in everyday life. Therefore, in view of the absence of any objective evidence provided by the original proponents of the PRS hypothesis, and the failure of subsequent empirical investigations to adequately support it, it may well be appropriate now to conclude that there is not, and never has been, any substance to the conjecture that people represent their world internally in a preferred mode which may be inferred from their choice of predicates and from their eye movements.
'These conclusions, and the failure of investigators to convincingly demonstrate the alleged benefits of predicate matching, seriously question the role of such a procedure in counselling."
And he ends:

'This verdict on NLP is .... an interim one. Einsprech and Forman are probably correct in insisting that the effectiveness of NLP therapy undertaken in authentic clinical contexts of trained practitioners has not yet been properly investigated. If it turns out to be the case that these therapeutic procedures are indeed as rapid and powerful as is claimed, no one will rejoice more than the present author. If however these claims fare no better than the ones already investigated then the final verdict on NLP will be a harsh one indeed."
If you would like to read the article in more detail, or follow up the references cited, you will find it in the volume Hypnosis: current clinical. experimental and forensic practices, edited by Michael Heap and published by Croom Helm in 1988. It contains many other articles of great interest by reputable workers.

I know that some members of the NCP are enthusiastic users of NLP techniques and I would be interested to know their response to this article. On the other hand if you are a member who has tried to use the indirect ways of deducing a person's PRS andfailed, or have tried to pace the presumed PRS and not gained noticeably greater rapport than usual, then you may find comfort in the thought that the fault may not lie in you.

In my own experience a simple question such as, "When you say that do you mean that your actually picture .... to yourself?" is answered happily and openly by people, so that there is no need for devious, indirect or doubtful ways of finding out in detail how their minds are working.

 

See more Alternative Therapy Articles

 



Books on Complementary and Alternative Therapies

Herbal-Therapy The Guide to Herbalism, Herbal Medicines, Natural Cures and Therapies.

Therapy Related Articles & Notes